Trick wrote:
Arf, booyah to all the people here who made a profit? Hmmm. Or booyah to the people here who lost out? Nope I still don't get it

My assumption is generally that hoarder-hating = sour grapes.
:shrug:
My general policy with potential avatar items is to sell enough to at least break even AFTER the avatar is found on the server and BEFORE the news is synced, in case the avatar turns out to be clickable. So in the end, while I only made a few thousand NP off the Scarabugs (should have sold a few more before I went out for the day, oh well), I didn't lose any NP. Not bad given that the cheapest I bought one for was 6k. Essentially, IMHO, the safest way to make NP off avatars is to be an early hoarder selling to late hoarders. (Of course, this only works if you're an early hoarder...)
If you buy enough, and buy early enough, sometimes one can make a considerable profit even if the avatar turns out to be unrelated to the item. IIRC I did pretty well off the Achyfi avatar even though it had nothing to do with Achyfi in the end.