I guess it's got it's ups and downs, but as does almost any other aspect of the site, you know?
Trades = scam hole
Auctions = scam hole
Shops= scam hole
Neoboards = Ice Palace
-but also-
Trades = a great place to trade, sell and buy UB items and find good deals
Auctions = fun and fast paced place to get great deals on all sorts of items
Shops = to sell your stuff
Neoboards = a place to make friends, talk to others, etc.
Every feature has it's ups and downs. But I can see more good coming out of the shortcut than bad. Even a drop down list like watericesage suggested would work. And if someone is dumb enough to fall for a scam involving the shortcut, then they don't deserve to even use the shortcut in the first place. TNT could make a little warning, telling their users of the possible scam danger.
And everconfused, I can imagine the annoyance you suffer whenever something on the toolbar changes, but I'm talking about the shortcut being just at the top of the toolbar, right next to your username. Out of the way of most things, yet easy to get to. So very little, if any changes to personal lookups would be neccesary
r4che1, you got a good point there. But like I said before, a lotta people just can't be botherd setting a page to favourates. Too much hassle, and like Zero said, some people's favourates are really clogged up (like mine

)
I'm just sick of having to go through two or more pages, just to find what I'm looking for. I know it's not much, but I'd still really prefer if I could (in one click) go to the shop wiz, my shop, my inventory, the battledome, whatever. It'd make life just that -little- bit easier, and if someone is nervous using this feature, then they simply don't have to use it.